Hacker News

Di rial kɔst fɔ random I/O

Kɔmɛnt dɛn

18 min read Via vondra.me

Mewayz Team

Editorial Team

Hacker News

Yu Biznɛs Sɔftwɛl Slɔ pas aw i fɔ bi — Ɛn Random I/O Na di Invisible Culprit

Ɛvri tɛm we kɔstɔma kɔmplen bɔt wan slo dashbɔd, ɛvri tɛm we yu tim wet fɔ ɛkstra tri sɛkɔn fɔ mek wan ripɔt lod, ɛn ɛvri tɛm we yu chɛk-ɔut pej lɔs pɔsin we bay am bikɔs i nɔ gɛt peshɛnt — strɔng chans de fɔ mek random I/O de kwayɛt wan dreyn yu revenyu. Na nɔto buzzword we dɛn kip fɔ database injinia dɛn. Na wan bɔtul-nɛk we pɔsin kin mɛzhɔ, we kin tek bɔku mɔni we de ayd insay klos to ɛvri biznɛs aplikeshɔn, frɔm CRM lukɔp to invɔys jɛnɛreshɔn. Fɔ ɔndastand in rial kɔst nɔto jɔs tɛknikal ɛgzampul — na faynɛns wan. Di kɔmni dɛn we nɔ de pe atɛnshɔn to am de pe di prayz pan klawd bil dɛn we dɔn blo, kɔstɔma dɛn we dɔn lɔs, ɛn tim dɛn we stɔp fɔ wet na skrin dɛn we fɔ lod wantɛm wantɛm.

Wetin Random I/O Rili Min (Ɛn Wetin Mek I Dia)

Na in kɔr, I/O — input/output — na di prɔses fɔ rid ɛn rayt data to stɔrɔj. We yu aplikeshɔn de tek rɛkɔd frɔm database, lod fayl dɛn frɔm disk, ɔ rayt transakshɔn lɔg, i de du I/O ɔpreshɔn. Dɛn ɔpreshɔn ya kin kam insay tu flawa dɛn: sikwinshal ɛn random. Sikyud I/O de rid ɔ rayt data insay kɔntigyuɔs blɔk, lɛk fɔ rid buk frɔm di biginin te to di ɛnd. Random I/O de jomp rawnd we yu nɔ go ebul fɔ no, lɛk fɔ flip to pej 47, dɔn pej 3, dɔn pej 812.

Di pefɔmɛns gap bitwin dɛn tu patɛns ya de mek pɔsin sɔprayz. Na tradishɔnal had drayv, sikwinshal rid kin ajɔst truput we na 150-200 MB/s, we random rid kin krawl bɔku tɛm na 0.5-1.5 MB/s — difrɛns we na 100x ɔ mɔ. Ivin pan mɔdan NVMe SSD dɛn, we rili impruv random I/O pefɔmɛns, di gap stil de frɔm 5x to 20x dipen pan di woklɔd. We yu biznɛs aplikeshɔn de gi tawzin smɔl, skata rid riŋwe fɔ wan sɛkɔn — pul wan kɔstɔma nem ya, wan invɔys layn aytem de, wan pɔmishɔn chɛk ɔdasay — ɛni hop de introduks latɛns we dɛn mɛzhɔ insay maykrosɛkɔnd we de kɔmpawnd insay sɛkɔn dɛn fɔ rial yuza wet tɛm.

Di fizik nɔ chenj insay dikɛd ia: fɔ akses data we skata akɔdin to stɔrɔj na fondamɛnt slo pas fɔ strim am in ɔda. Wetin dɔn chenj na di skel we di mɔdan aplikeshɔn dɛn de jenarayz random I/O, we de mek i nɔ pɔsibul fɔ ignore in kɔst.

Di Hiden Taks pan Ɛvri Biznɛs Ɔpreshɔn

Tink bɔt wetin kin apin we wan yuza opin CRM dɛshbɔd. Di aplikeshɔn de aks wan kɔstɔma tebul, jɔyn am wit di aktiviti lɔg dɛn we dɛn jɔs dɔn mek, pul di valyu dɛn we gɛt fɔ du wit di dil, chɛk di yuza pɔmishɔn, lod notis kɔnt, ɛn tek di displei prɛferɛns. Ɛni wan pan dɛn kwɛstyɔn dɛn ya kin tɔch difrɛn tebul dɛn we dɛn dɔn kip na difrɛn say dɛn na disk. Wan dashbɔd we de sho 50 kɔstɔma rɛkɔd dɛn kin mek 300 to 500 random I/O ɔpreshɔn ɔnda di hud. Multiply dat wit 200 kɔnkɔrɛnt yuza dɛn insay pik biznɛs awa, ɛn yu database sava de prosɛs ɔp to 100,000 random rid dɛn fɔ wan sɛkɔn.

Dis nɔto hypothetical. Wan 2024 stɔdi we Pɛkɔna bin du, sho se di database woklɔd dɛn we nɔ fayn fɔ ɔptimayz kin spɛn te to 68% pan dɛn ɔl ɛgzikishɔn tɛm fɔ wet pan I/O ɔpreshɔn, wit random akses patɛn we na di praymar ɔfɛnda. Fɔ wan SaaS kɔmni we de sav tawzin biznɛs, dis de translet dairekt to ay infrastukchɔ kɔst. Klaud prɔvayda dɛn de chaj bay IOPS (I/O ɔpreshɔn pan sɛkɔn), ɛn random I/O-hɛvi woklɔd kin push mɔnt stɔrɔj bil frɔm ɔndrɛd to tɛn tawzin dɔla — nɔto bikɔs ɔf data volyum, bɔt bikɔs ɔf akses patɛn.

Di kɔst de go bifo pas infrastukchɔ. Ɛvri 100 milisekɔnd we dɛn ad di pej lod tɛm de ridyus di kɔnvɔshɔn rɛt bay lɛk 7%, akɔdin to risach frɔm Akamai. We random I/O ad ful sɛkɔn to yu invɔys jɛnɛreshɔn ɔ ripɔt lod, yu nɔ jɔs de bɔn kɔmpyuta — yu de bɔn revenyu.

Usay Biznɛs Aplikeshɔn dɛn de Blid Pɔfɔmɛnshɔn

Nɔto ɔl di ficha dɛn we dɛn mek ikwal we i kam pan I/O patɛn. Sɔm pan di biznɛs ɔpreshɔn dɛn we kɔmɔn pas ɔl na di wan dɛn bak we de du bad pas ɔl fɔ random akses:

    we dɛn kɔl
  • Sɔch ɛn filta: We yu aks kwɛstyɔn akɔdin to bɔku fil dɛm (nem, de, stetɔs, tag dɛm) de fos di database fɔ skan indeks dɛm we skata akɔdin to stɔrɔj, we de mek ebi ebi random rid
  • Dashbɔd agregeshɔn: Fɔ sɔm di revenyu, fɔ kɔnt di aktif yuza dɛn, ɔ fɔ kɔl di invɔys dɛn we dɔn ovadu, yu nid fɔ tɔch bɔku bɔku row dɛn we de spred akɔdin to difrɛn data pej dɛn
  • Pɛmishɔn chɛk: Rol-bɛs akses kɔntrol na mɔlti-tɛnant pletfɔm dɛn kin nid bɔku lukɔp fɔ ɛni rikwest — yuza → rol → pɔmishɔn → risɔs — ɛni wan de hit difrɛn tebul dɛn
  • Ripɔt jenɛreshɔn: Mɔnt pe rɔl ripɔt, flit mentenɛns sɔmari, ɔ HR analitiks de pul data frɔm dɔzɛn tebul dɛn wan tɛm
  • Ral-taym notis: We yu chɛk fɔ nyu mɛsej, task ɔpdet, ɛn sistɛm alert akɔdin to mɔdyul dɛn de mek wan kɔnstant strim fɔ smɔl, random kwɛstyɔn dɛn

Di patɛn klia: di mɔ modul ɛn ficha dɛn we wan pletfɔm de gi, na di mɔ I/O pat dɛn de bɔku. Wan simpul link-in-bio tul kin mek 10 kwɛstyɔn dɛn fɔ ɛni pej we dɛn lod. Wan ful biznɛs ɔpreshɔn sistɛm wit CRM, invoys, HR, pe rɔl, bukin, ɛn analitiks mɔdyul dɛn — lɛk wetin Mewayz de gi akɔdin to in 207 mɔdyul dɛn — kin tiorikali jenarayz ɔndrɛd. Di difrɛns bitwin wan pletfɔm we de fil instant ɛn wan we de fil slɔg bɔku tɛm de kam dɔŋ to aw dɛn de manej dɛn I/O patɛn dɛn de wit sɛns biɛn di scene.

Wetin Mek Fɔ Trowe Hadwɔd Na di Prɔblɛm Nɔ De Wok

Di instinkt we aplikeshɔn dɛn slo na fɔ ɔpgrɛd. Big big sava, fasta SSD, mɔ RAM. Ɛn pan ɔl we di hadwae improvement dɛn de ɛp, dɛn de fala wan kɔv fɔ diminishing ritɔn we de mek CFO dɛn nɔ kɔmfyut. Dabl yu database sava in RAM frɔm 64GB to 128GB kin mek di kesh hit ret bɛtɛ frɔm 92% to 96% — wan mininful gens, bɔt di ɔda 4% pan di kesh mis stil hit stɔrɔj ​​wit random I/O. Tripl yu IOPS alɔkeshɔn pan AWS frɔm 3,000 to 10,000 de kɔst lɛk $450 mɔ fɔ wan mɔnt bɔt i kin jɔs impɔtant p99 rispɔns tɛm bay 30%.

Di rial prɔblɛm na akitekchɔral. Bɔku tɛm, Random I/O na wan sayn fɔ dip tin dɛn: indeks dɛn we nɔ de ɔ we dɛn nɔ disayn fayn, N+1 kwɛstyɔn patɛn usay di aplikeshɔn de mek wan database kɔl fɔ ɛni aytem instead fɔ batch, ɔva-nɔmal skima dɛn we nid fayv tebul jɔyn fɔ wan displei rɔw, ɛn we nɔ gɛt rid riplik ɔ kesh layers. Hadwɔd ɔpgrɛd kin trit di sik. Akitekchral ɔptimayzeshɔn de trit di kɔz.

Di I/O opareshɔn we dia pas ɔl na di wan we nɔ fɔ de insay di fɔs ples. Fɔ ɛvri dala we dɛn spɛn pan fasta stɔrɔj, tɛn sɛnt we dɛn spɛn fɔ kwɛstyɔn ɔptimayzeshɔn de gi bɛtɛ rizɔlt. Di kɔmni dɛm we win pan pefɔmɛns nɔ de spɛnd pas dɛn kɔmpitishɔn — dɛn de ɔt-tink dɛn data akses patɛn.

💡 DID YOU KNOW?

Mewayz replaces 8+ business tools in one platform

CRM · Invoicing · HR · Projects · Booking · eCommerce · POS · Analytics. Free forever plan available.

Start Free →
we yu kin yuz

Praktikal Strateji dɛm we rili Ridyus Random I/O

Fɔ ridyus random I/O nɔ nid fɔ rayt bak yu aplikeshɔn kɔmplit wan. I nid fɔ chenj di we aw dɛn de kip, akses, ɛn kesh di data we dɛn want, we dɛn go ebul fɔ mɛzhɔ. Na di strateji dɛm we de gi di ays impak:

    we dɛn kɔl
  1. Impliment agresiv kweshon batching. Riples N+1 kweshon patna wit eager loading. If yu dashbɔd lod 50 kɔstɔma dɛn ɛn dɛn aktiviti we dɛn jɔs du, tek ɔl di 50 aktiviti sɛt dɛn na wan kwɛstyɔn yuz WHERE customer_id IN (...) pas 50 wan wan lukɔp dɛn. Dis wan kin ridyus random I/O bay 80% pan list views.
  2. Yuz kɔmpɔzit indeks dɛn stratejik wan. Wan kɔmpɔzit indeks na (tenant_id, status, created_at) de mek di database satisfay kɔmɔn filta kwɛstyɔn dɛn wit wan sikwinshal indeks skan instead ɔf bɔku random lukɔp dɛn akɔdin to difrɛn indeks dɛn.
  3. Introdyus wan kesh layt wit intɛligent invalidɛshɔn. Kesh we dɛn kin akses bɔku tɛm bɔt dɛn nɔ kin chenj di data — yuza pɔmishɔn, ɔganayzeshɔn sɛtin, mɔdyul kɔnfigyushɔn — na mɛmori. Redis ɔ Memcached kin sav dɛn tin ya insay maykrosɛkɔnd, we de pul bɔku bɔku random rid dɛn pan wan minit.
  4. Pri-kɔmpyut agregeshɔn. Insted fɔ kɔl di mɔnt revenyu ɔ edkɔnt pan ɛvri dashbɔd lod, rɔn agregeshɔn wok dɛn pan wan schedule ɛn kip di rizɔlt dɛn. Tred smɔl data freshnɛs fɔ wan big ridyushɔn pan rial-taym random I/O.
  5. Patishɔn big tebul dɛn bay akses patɛn. If 90% pan di kwɛstyɔn dɛn tɔch data frɔm di las 30 dez, patishɔn yu tebul dɛn bay deti rɛnj so di aktiv patishɔn go de hot na kesh we istri data sidɔm kol pan stɔrɔj we shɔt.

Dis no bi ekzotik teknik. Dɛn na di sem patɛns we de alaw pletfɔm dɛn we de sav ɔndrɛd tawzin yuza dɛn fɔ mentɛn sab-sɛkɔn rispɔns tɛm akɔs kɔmpleks, mɔlti-mɔdyul intafɛs dɛn. We Mewayz bil bak in akitekchɔ fɔ V2 — skel frɔm wan singl link-in-bio tul to wan 207-mɔdyul biznɛs OS we de sav ova 138,000 yuza dɛn — fɔ ɔptimayz I/O akses patɛn bin fawndeshɔn fɔ mek da ɛkspɛnshɔn de viable witout multiply infrastrakcha kɔst prɔpɔshɔnal wan.

Di Kɔmpawnd Ifɛkt pan Yuz Ɛkspiriɛns ɛn Ritɛnshɔn

Pɔfɔmɛnshɔn nɔto jɔs bakɛnd kɔnsyans — na prɔdak ficha. Google in risach dɔn sho ɔltɛm se 53% pan di wan dɛn we de yuz mobayl kin lɛf wan pej we kin tek lɔng pas 3 sɛkɔn fɔ lod. Fɔ biznɛs aplikeshɔn usay di wan dɛn we de yuz am kin intarakt dɔzɛn tɛm pan de, di tolɛreshɔn kin ivin smɔl. Wan pe rol manija we de rɔn ripɔt ɛvri wik, wan HR lida we de rivyu aplikɛnt dɛn, ɔ wan sɛls rep we de chɛk di paip layn stetɔs — dɛn yuza ya de divɛlɔp wan intuitiv sɛns fɔ spid. Dɛn nɔ kin artikul "di random I/O latɛns pan di invɔys agregeshɔn kwɛstyɔn tu ay," bɔt dɛn go se "dis softwe de fil slo" ɛn bigin fɔ evalyu ɔda we dɛn.

Di kɔmpawnd ifɛkt na sɔntin we pɔsin kin mɛzhɔ. Wan pletfɔm we de lod dashbɔd insay 800ms instead ɔf 2.4 sɛkɔn nɔ jɔs de fil 3x fast — i de chenj di we aw yu de yuz am. Di wan dɛn we de yuz am kin chɛk di data mɔ ɛn mɔ, dɛn kin fɛn mɔ modul dɛn, ɛn dɛn kin intagret di tul mɔ dip wan insay dɛn wokflɔ. Hכy εngajmεnt de drεb hכy ritεnshכn, we de drεb hכy layf tεm valyu. Slak bin fambul fɔ atribyut wan impɔtant pat pan in fɔs growth to obsesiv pefɔmɛns ɔptimayzeshɔn, we i no se spid insɛf na bin kɔmpitishɔn moat.

Fɔ ɔl-in-wan biznɛs pletfɔm, dis ifɛkt de bɔku akɔdin to ɛvri mɔdyul. If CRM fast bɔt invoys slo, di we aw pipul dɛn de si di wan ol pletfɔm de sɔfa. Kɔnsistɛns fɔ pefɔmɛns akɔs ficha dɛn — frɔm bukin manejmɛnt to flit trakin to analitiks — nid kɔnsistɛns ɔptimayz I/O patɛn ɔlsay, nɔto jɔs insay di mɔdyul dɛn we pɔsin kin si mɔ.

Mɛzhɔ Wetin Impɔtant: Mek Random I/O Visible

Yu nɔ go ebul fɔ fiks wetin yu nɔ ebul fɔ si. Di fɔs step fɔ adrɛs random I/O kɔst na fɔ mek yu injinɛri ɛn ɔpreshɔn tim dɛn si dɛn. Mɔdan ɔbsabiliti tul dɛn lɛk Datadog, Nyu Rilik, ɔ ivin opin-sɔs sɔlvishɔn dɛn lɛk Prometheus wit Grafana kin trak IOPS patɛn, kwɛstyɔn latɛns distribyushɔn, ɛn kesh hit rɛt insay rial tɛm. Di mɛtrik dɛm we impɔtant pas ɔl na:

    we dɛn kɔl
  • p95 ɛn p99 kwɛstyɔn latɛns: Avrej latɛns de ayd di pen. Di 95th ɛn 99th pasɛntayl de sho wetin yu sloslo — ɛn mɔs frustrated — yuza dɛn kin rili ɛkspiriɛns
  • IOPS brekdaun bay rid vs. rayt, sikwinshal vs. random: Dis de sho if yu woklɔd na I/O-baund ɛn us kayn I/O de dominate
  • Cache hit ratio: Wan ratio we de dɔŋ 95% pan wan sistɛm we dɛn dɔn tyun fayn fayn wan de sho se data akses patɛn we nɔ de sav frɔm mɛmori
  • Kwɛri kɔnt fɔ ɛni pej lod: If wan yuza akshɔn trig pas 20-30 database kwɛstyɔn, i go bi se na ɔptimayzeshɔn chans de

Arm wit dis data, tim dɛn kin prayoritɛd di ayest-impakt ɔptimayzeshɔn pas fɔ gɛs. Di biznɛs dɛn we de trit I/O pefɔmɛns lɛk fɔs-klas mɛtrik — alongsay aptaym, mistek rɛt, ɛn yuz satisfayshɔn — kɔnsistɛntli de delivr fasta prodak pan lɔwa kɔst. Insay wan makit usay di wan dɛn we de yuz am de ɛkspɛkt se biznɛs tul dɛn go ansa lɛk di kɔshɔma ap dɛn, da disiplin de nɔto opshɔnal. Na di difrɛns bitwin wan pletfɔm we de skel gras to 138,000 yuza ɛn wan we de buk ɔnda in yon kɔmplisiti.

Strimlayn Yu Biznɛs wit Mewayz

Mewayz de briŋ 207 biznɛs mɔdyul dɛn insay wan pletfɔm — CRM, invoys, prɔjek manejmɛnt, ɛn mɔ. Join 138,000+ yuza dɛm we mek dɛn wokflɔ simpul.

Start Fri Tide →
, we yu kin yuz

Kwɛshɔn dɛn we dɛn kin aks bɔku tɛm

Wetin na random I/O, ɛn wetin mek i slo so?

Random I/O kin apin we wan sistem de rid ɔ rayt smɔl smɔl data frɔm difrɛn, nɔ-sikwinshal ples dɛn na wan stɔrɔj drayv. Nɔ lɛk sikwinshal I/O (we yu de rid fayl stat-to-finish), di rid/rayt ed fɔ jomp rawnd ɔltɛm, we de mek impɔtant fizik dilɛys. Dis na di praymar rizin we mek wan database query we de fetch skata records de slo pas fɔ strim big vidio fayl, ivin if di total data amount smɔl.

Aw random I/O de impɔk mi biznɛs ɔpreshɔn dɛn dairekt wan?

I de impak di yuza ɛkspiriɛns ɛn prodaktiviti dairekt wan. Di we aw di aplikeshɔn kin ansa sloslo kin mek di kɔstɔma dɛn at pwɛl, ɛn dis kin mek dɛn lɛf di kat ɛn sɔpɔt tikɛt dɛn. Fɔ di wokman dɛn, di CRM dɛn we nɔ de wok tranga wan ɛn di tin dɛn we dɛn de yuz fɔ ripɔt kin west valyu tɛm. Dɛn dilɛys ya kin translet to tin dɛn we pɔsin kin si: di sɛl we i lɔs, di wokman dɛn we nɔ de wok fayn, ɛn i kin ambɔg di gudnem we yu brand gɛt fɔ di we aw i de ansa. Ɛvri sɛkɔn we di latɛns gɛt mɔni valyu.

Dis no bi jis wan hadwae prohblem? A nɔ go jɔs bay fasta SSD dɛn?

Wɛl fasta SSD dɛn kin ɛp, dɛn na sɔlv we kin tek bɔku mɔni ɛn bɔku tɛm dɛn nɔ kin kɔmplit. Di rut kɔz kin bi sɔftwɛl we nɔ ebul fɔ wok fayn ɛn we de du bɔku smɔl smɔl, skata database rikwest dɛn. Optimizing aplikeshɔn kɔd ɛn database kwɛstyɔn fɔ minimiz random I/O na fa mɔ ifɛktiv. Sɔlwɛshɔn dɛn lɛk Mewayz, wit in 207 mɔdyul dɛn we dɛn dɔn bil bifo tɛm we de stat na $19/mo, dɛn mek am fɔ mek di data akses patɛn dɛn izi wan.

Wetin na di fɔs step fɔ no if random I/O na mi bɔtulnɛk?

Start wit yu aplikeshɔn in pefɔmɛns monitarin tul dɛn. Luk fɔ database mɛtrik we de sho ay rid/rayt ɔpreshɔn pan sɛkɔn (IOPS) kɔpl wit slo kwɛstyɔn tɛm. Profayl yu aplikeshɔn fɔ no di kwɛstyɔn dɛn we yu kin aks ɔltɛm ɛn we smɔl smɔl. If wan yuza akshɔn trig dɔzɛn wan wan database kɔl instead ɔf sɔm efyushɔn wan dɛn, yu go mɔs dɔn fɛn wan random I/O ishu we nid fɔ adrɛs.

Try Mewayz Free

All-in-one platform for CRM, invoicing, projects, HR & more. No credit card required.

Start managing your business smarter today

Join 30,000+ businesses. Free forever plan · No credit card required.

Ready to put this into practice?

Join 30,000+ businesses using Mewayz. Free forever plan — no credit card required.

Start Free Trial →

Ready to take action?

Start your free Mewayz trial today

All-in-one business platform. No credit card required.

Start Free →

14-day free trial · No credit card · Cancel anytime